The great battle race of Jeffrey Herlings vs. Eli Tomac 2022 In motocross, a debate has raged for 50 years – are European MXGP or American AMA riders faster?

Americans Want You to Forget About This Race: The Clash of Titans in Motocross

In the high-octane world of motocross, debates about which riders are the fastest have ignited passionate discussions for decades. For 50 years, fans and experts have argued whether European MXGP or American AMA riders hold the edge.

However, a landmark event in 2017 provided a rare opportunity to directly compare the two elite groups of riders, centering on a thrilling showdown between Jeffrey Herlings and Eli Tomac.

Jeffrey Herlings, a dominant force in the MXGP series, and Eli Tomac, a powerhouse in the AMA Supercross

and Motocross series, represent the pinnacle of their respective circuits.

Their rivalry was not just a meeting of two top athletes but also a symbolic clash between two differing philosophies and styles of motocross racing.

The 2017 season was notable for the extraordinary alignment that allowed this head-to-head battle to occur. For fans, this was a chance to settle the long-standing debate about whether European or American riders were superior.

Herlings, known for his aggressive riding style and technical prowess on the MXGP circuit, was pitted against Tomac, who had established himself as a dominant force in the AMA series with his explosive speed and consistency.

Their confrontation was anticipated as a defining moment in motocross history. Yet, despite the immense excitement and hype surrounding this race, it has been surprisingly downplayed in discussions about the greatest motocross races of all time. The reasons for this selective memory are multifaceted.

One major factor is the inherent complexity and variability of motocross racing. Conditions, bike setups, and even race day circumstances can profoundly impact performance, making it difficult to draw definitive conclusions from a single race.

Additionally, both riders have continued to excel in their respective series, further complicating any attempt to declare a clear-cut winner of the debate.

Moreover, the marketing and media landscape play significant roles in shaping the narrative around such events.

In a sport driven by promotional opportunities and sponsorships, the focus often shifts to ongoing rivalries, emerging talents, or next big races, rather than revisiting past showdowns. This has led to a gradual fading of the 2017 race from the spotlight.

Nevertheless, the clash between Herlings and Tomac in 2017 remains a pivotal moment for motocross enthusiasts.

It was a rare intersection of two worlds that are usually separated by the Atlantic, showcasing the high level of talent on both sides of the pond. For those who witnessed it, the race was more than just a competition; it was a symbolic convergence of motocross greatness.

In retrospect, while the race may not have been preserved as a legendary moment in the sport’s history, it serves as a reminder of the thrilling possibilities that arise when the best from different worlds come together.

The debate about whether European or American riders are faster continues, but the 2017 race between Jeffrey Herlings and Eli Tomac remains a testament to the incredible talent and competitive spirit that define the sport of motocross.